Common Benjamin Graham Misquotes

contenu

Warren Buffett's mentor — and the founder of Value Investing — is misquoted frequently today, often due to recent modifications to his books.

Traduction en cours...

Benjamin Graham

Traduction en cours...

Benjamin Graham was Warren Buffett's mentor. Buffett wrote the preface to Graham's book The Intelligent Investor, describing it as "by far the best book about investing ever written". The book was reprinted recently with commentary by Jason Zweig.

Traduction en cours...

GrahamValue's list of famous Value Investing quotes includes a curated list of actual Graham quotes.

Traduction en cours...

Misquotes

Traduction en cours...

But Graham has probably been misquoted, and had his ideas misrepresented, more than anyone else in finance. Given below are some of the more prominent examples.

Traduction en cours...

1. Formula

Traduction en cours...

The so-called Benjamin Graham Formula is a classic example of a Graham misquote that was possibly caused by the recent modifications to his books. The topic has been thoroughly explored in a dedicated article.

Traduction en cours...

Note: The Graham Number and NCAV are often applied incorrectly today as well. But they are more misused than misquoted.

Traduction en cours...

2. Preface

Traduction en cours...

As another example, neither of the highlighted "Graham quotes" in this recently published article by a popular financial writer are actually by Graham.

Traduction en cours...

The first quote about a "sound intellectual framework" is from Buffett's preface to The Intelligent Investor, and the second one about "behavioral discipline" is from Jason Zweig's commentary.

Traduction en cours...

Note: The text in the middle of the image has been removed to avoid identifying the author and the website.

Traduction en cours...

3. Commentary

Traduction en cours...

These are more examples of bits of Jason Zweig's commentary from 2006 being attributed to Graham. This is actually so common an occurrence today, that listing all such instances here is nearly impossible.

Traduction en cours...

Buffett's preface is much older in comparison (1986), but everything seems fair game today in the world of online financial articles.

Traduction en cours...

4. Selling

Traduction en cours...

Another possible misquote is Graham's rumored instruction to sell a stock at "50-100% gains or after 2-3 years", which is not included in any of the sections on selling stocks in his books.

Traduction en cours...

Misconceptions

Traduction en cours...

A lot of the common arguments against Value Investing arise from misunderstandings about Graham's full framework.

Traduction en cours...

1. Oversimplification

Traduction en cours...

Detractors usually restrict themselves to the Graham Number or the NCAV method, without the supporting qualitative criteria; or use the completely misunderstood Benjamin Graham formula.

Traduction en cours...

After thus starting with the wrong premises, they end up with the wrong conclusions. This is also not helped by the fact that many analysts too promote these overly simplified Value Investing methods over Graham's full framework.

Traduction en cours...

2. Selectivity

Traduction en cours...

Another reason people have been observed to criticize Graham's framework is because of its extreme selectivity. Graham stocks seem hard to find, or their favorite blue-chips and current holdings fail to pass the Graham rules, and so they reject the framework.

Traduction en cours...

This selectivity is actually the strongest argument in favor of Graham's framework. It would seem obvious that one's stocks should fit one's framework and not the other way around. The framework of Warren Buffett's mentor — Benjamin Graham — is specifically designed to reject stocks rather than clear them.

Traduction en cours...

Graham's own opinion on the ephemeral nature of simplistic investment strategies is recorded his rejection of one of his own earlier such strategies, the CAPE (Cyclically Adjusted P/E) Ratio; which is also now often wrongly recommended as one of his approved strategies.

Traduction en cours...

2a. False Negatives

Traduction en cours...

It’s always better in investing to have a false negative than a false positive. The idea is to always try and err on the side of caution. This makes finding Graham stocks harder, but also makes the process safer; ergo, provides a better Margin of Safety.

Traduction en cours...

2b. Special Situations

Traduction en cours...

Unfortunately, such extreme selectivity also makes Graham's methods unpopular. People don't like methods that reject most of their favorite stocks.

Traduction en cours...

But not all stocks failing Graham's rules are necessarily bad investments. They may fall under Special Situations. So even when stocks don't clear them, Graham's rules give a clear quantifiable measure of a stock's Margin of Safety.

Traduction en cours...

Graham designed and back-tested his Value Investing framework for over 50 years, to deliver the best possible long-term results.

Traduction en cours...

3. Short Selling

Traduction en cours...

Graham did not explicitly oppose shorting, but simply wrote that though the "principle is sound... it is distinctly not an easy art to master."

Traduction en cours...

Online Articles

Traduction en cours...

Financial articles online today are replete with such misquotes and misattributions that are often used to justify something completely contradictory to what the original author was trying to convey.

Traduction en cours...

Many of the misconceptions and misquotes above stem from a basic lack of understanding of what science is, and how it works.

Traduction en cours...

Would it be wise to trust such writers who get simple quotes and sources wrong, to get complex statistical analyses right? There is probably good reason why the role of objective numbers in investments is often downplayed today, and subjective written analyses and Story Stocks are promoted instead.

Traduction en cours...

Actual Investing

Traduction en cours...

While winging it may work for churning out financial articles en masse for social platforms, actual investing requires obsessive attention to numbers.

Traduction en cours...

There are Value Investing services out there charging $600 a year to compare a handful of stocks, sometimes using valuation techniques Graham actually warned against (such as the Ben Graham Formula). Even the genuine ones usually apply just the Graham Number or the NCAV, without the supporting qualitative criteria.

Traduction en cours...

GrahamValue, on the other hand, is built to follow Graham's principles faithfully; in both letter and spirit.

Traduction en cours...

Buffett Explains

Traduction en cours...

Warren Buffett explains how, contrary to a common misconception today, Graham was uninfluenced by the Great Depression.

Traduction en cours...